Choose Family Over Frenzy

As posted on Huffington Post.

When I turned on my computer today, I had 7 emails from vendors announcing special low prices – Black Friday deals – available all week. The biggest discounts advertised were on electronics,which wasn’t a surprise since November is considered “electronics buying month” within the retail industry. I waded through the Black Friday junk mail, tapping away at my delete button, to find the one email I sought: the message from my neighbor with the menu, schedule and guest list for this Thursday’s Thanksgiving gathering.

Now, revisionist history aside, Thanksgiving is a great holiday. It is two full days during which most people in the U.S. are liberated from work and school. It comes at a time when the days are getting shorter, trees have lost their leaves, and we’re pulling the sweaters out from the back of our overstuffed closets. It’s the perfect time to cozy up and nest with friends and family. In the midst of our hectic year-end bustle, we get to spend two days pausing, recharging, looking into the faces of loved ones rather than into our computer screens. And, of course, remembering those who can’t be with us.

There’s one mother I especially think of on Black Friday: Marie Tellismond. Two years ago on Black Friday, Marie lost her 34 year old son, Jdimytai Damour.

Jdimytai – known as Jimmy to his friends – had taken temporary job at a Walmart store in New York State, near his home. When the store opened at 5:00 in the morning, the crowds of shoppers – many of whom had been waiting in the cold for hours to score good deals – stormed the doors and trampled Jdimytai as he struggled to protect a pregnant woman from the stampede.

Jdimytai was a college student and his mother said he hoped to be a teacher one day. He liked watching football and eating his mother’s cooking. In an interview after the tragedy, she dabbed her eyes and said: “I don’t have anybody else.”

Now, I’ve never met Marie Tellismond, but as a fellow mother, I am pretty sure she would give anything to have a day with her son again. Losing, or even coming close to losing someone we love, makes us get our priorities straight really really fast.

Most of us have a choice this Friday that Marie Tellismound no longer has. We have a choice to stay put with loved ones, to play board games and eat leftovers and maybe even watch a football game together. Or we can chose to leave the warmth of our beds before dawn, to sit in our cars in a parking lot at some mall and to spend the day searching for low prices on products which we don’t really need and often don’t even want, but getting them is all part of the Black Friday Frenzy.

Let’s opt out of the frenzy this year.

Our out of control consumption has taken a toll on the planet, on our family budgets, and on workers from FoxConn in China to Walmart in New York. And it has taken a toll on the quality of our lives at home.

We have more and cooler stuff than our parents and grandparents could have ever imagined, but we pay dearly. We spend more time working and shopping than they did and we spend much less time in leisure, on vacation and with friends. What is the use of a brand new Pottery Barn table if we don’t have a gang of friends and neighbors to gather around it?

If we’re going to figure out how to build an economy and society that is healthy for people and the planet, this Friday is a good place to start.

Let’s opt out of Black Friday. Choose family over frenzy.

posted by Annie Leonard
November 23, 2010
share this post:
tags:
, , , , , , , , ,
  • http://www.thefeistyempire.com/ Paul Hassing

    Wonderful post, Annie. And we don’t even have Thanksgiving in Australia. We did, however, get the story of poor Jdimytai on the news. I’ve been reading and watching your stuff for a while now, and I reckon you’re yet to strike a bung note. Thank you for your clear, resonant call. If you ever get hungry out here in the wilderness, you can have some of my honey-coated locusts. With best regards and deep respect, P. :)

  • Sara Ratliff

    Thank you for this essay, Ms. Leonard. This topic resonates deeply with me. Working eight straight years in corporate retail, I quickly learned to dread this phenomenon of mass hysteria known as Black Friday. I watched in terror at the parking lots packed with more people at one time than at any other time of the year at ridiculous hours for the sake of landing “deals” on merchandise. I experienced the long lines of grouchy, inconsiderate customers who cared only about their own purchases and getting through the line before everyone else. I saw possibly hundreds of rolls of wrapping paper that would be used once, ripped to shreds, and then thrown away to rot in landfills for eternity. Those employed in retail (and in restaurants, which have their own shopping-related ordeals to handle) are not allowed to take any time off and more than once was unable to attend family functions. They’re so busy busting their butts so that the general public can go ape-crazy to buy that “perfect Christmas” or that “hottest” gift that their children MUST have in order to be hip at school or believe in Santa that they can’t enjoy the essential joys of the season. The season has been reduced to a load of commercial hogwash anyway: the vast majority of gifts purchased are returned in that week between the day after Christmas and New Year’s Eve. That’s a fiasco unto itself. Sadly Jdimytai’s story is not an isolated incident. Reports of holiday shopping violence are common place. I myself camped outside my store of employment the weekend before Christmas in order to buy a Nintendo Wii and was almost assaulted by a crowd that gathered behind us who wanted our spots in line. Yes, my friends and I had our lives threatened because someone wanted to buy a stinking video game system out from under us. They were willing to beat us up to buy a toy. Human lives are worth more than toys. The past two years I’ve been able to escape, but I still dread even talk of it. I think it’s high time we crazy Americans re-evaluated out priorities when it comes to holidays.

  • http://dkzody.wordpress.com dkzody

    Excellent post. I keep saying, why do we need so much stuff?

  • http://greatpowerrace-universityofsouthcarolinaFacebook Anjana SUkumar

    Hi Annie!

    This is fabulous! I love your work, and on thanksgiving, i want to thank you for ur cntribution to the society with this wealth of information! I have learnt so much after coming to the US, and america is great only because of people like you! I have pledged not to buy anything, and even participated in a freecycling event on our campus. It is a great feeling to rebel against consumerism.

    I have even advocated online shopping with several of my friends, and i am happy that you helped me change his habit when my professor screened your movie in class. thank you. I chose my family over the frenzy, i did not even know about black friday till i saw some post on FB yday asking if i got any good deal..and boy I am glad I havent even looked at the deals, good strong spam filter. I instead sat on Facebook, and personally thanked 60-70 of my friends and family for their contribution to my life. I felt so overwhelmed and great at the end of the day, and no turkey too :D It was great.

    Thanks for everything!

  • http://shareable.net Neal Gorenflo

    About six years ago, I stopped holiday shopping and started a donation exchange instead. The holidays became so much more relaxing and meaningful. Here’s how I did it: http://ht.ly/3fTdy

    Start one in your family and give to The Story of Stuff project.

  • http://linh.wordpress.com Linh

    It’s sad that you have to write a post like this. Over the past few years, I’ve looked back at what I buy and why. It certainly fell on the side of “want” more often than “need.” I have consciously tried to change that behavior, to some success.

    I’m by no means perfect, nor do I advocate everyone needs to stop buying things. But I feel we all do need to step back and scale back some. Black Friday being the first thing that needs to go. The mentality it drives is just… plain insanity to me. Start of the shopping “season.” “Best” deals? It’s all hype to get you to buy. Most of the stuff is a marginally good deal. The “door busters” are usually very limited relative to the area a store serves. Why is the day after enjoying time with the family suddenly “shop til you drop?”

    I have personally made it a point to start advocating for childsplaycharity when black friday rolls around. I dunno if it does any good, or if it’s just a “makes-me-feel-good” thing, but I like to think it has some effect, even if minor.

  • http://whatisworking.com Linda H

    Annie, you are an inspiration. You have an entertaining, common sense approach to explaining a subject that is rare. If only the news could be more like you.

    You also seem to attract a group of visitors who create comments that are reasonable and uplifting, instead of angry and negative.

    I was also trying to bring a small voice of sanity to this verbal mayhem when I created the my blog – whatISworking blog. Your videos and writing made a profound impact on my thinking, thanks so much.

  • Chris Swingle

    First Unitarian Church in Rochester, NY, held its first-ever Black Friday service as an alternative to consumerism. A story in advance:
    http://www.democratandchronicle.com/article/20101121/NEWS0201/11210336/1005
    A video about the event:
    http://www.democratandchronicle.com/section/videonetwork#/Local+News/Church+aims+to+shift+focus+from+Black+Friday/56075166001/52274416001/689092384001

  • http://www.facebook.com/unstuff David Littlejohn

    Totally agree. Christmas and the Holidays shouldn’t be about giving each other more junk we don’t need. That’s why we’ve started a campaign to Unstuff Christmas. Check it out and help the cause at http://www.facebook.com/unstuff.

  • BR

    Hi, Great videos about stuff and electronics. You are a force doing something. There is an old saying, there is no such thing as bad publicity. If not for GB at FN, I would never have heard of you. Your stories are excellent and impactful, laying bare the truth like no one else. There is even more to the story. I would love to share what I know with you about the other side of commercialization that’s externalized. You have my e-mail. Thanks.